2010年3月23日火曜日

CLとTHの認識のズレ

Clip to Evernote
ADOCを開発した理由でも書いたが,CL中心実践(CCP)の,特に目標設定の認識においてCLとTHの間にズレがある.

つまりほとんどのTHは,自分は治療目標についてClと相談しながらやっているし,CLは目標設定過程に参加しているし,CLが目標設定に関与することが重要であると考えている.しかし,CLの約半数は目標設定をほとんど手伝っていないと答え,1/4のCLは目標設定に参加することは重要ではないと答えた.またCCPのプロセスには施設によって差があるとのこと.

まあ,ズレが有るのは仕方ないと思う.CL30名とTH11名という数がとても少ないし,その人たちを選んだ基準が不明確なので,この結果をそのまま受け入れるよりは,もう少しその辺を再検討してからズレについて判断する必要があるだろう.ただ臨床的な印象や,先行研究を概観する限りでは,このズレはもっとありそうな気がするが・・・.特に我が国ではその検証はされていないと思うので,やる価値は十分にある.

あなたの作業療法での目標は何ですか?
あなたは作業療法での目標設定に参加しましたか?
あなたにとって作業療法の目標設定に参加することは重要ですか?

などなど,CLとTHにインタビューをして確認してみる必要があると思われる.
ADOCによってCCPプロセスに関するCLの認識が変化するかどうか検証してみたい.
そのためのツールだから.


Kinsuk K. Maitra, Frances Erway
Perception of Client-Centered Practicein Occupational Therapists and Their Clients
AJOT. 2006(60) 298-310.

OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study was to comparatively analyze the perceptions of clients and occupational therapists regarding their involvement in the process of client-centered practice. METHOD. Participants (11 occupational therapists, 30 clients) in adult/geriatric health care facilities were each engaged in a semistructured interview to determine their perceptions of client-centered practice, specifically in the goal-setting process. Descriptive statistics were used to analyze the item data. In addition, one-way analysis of variance was computed to identify the differences of opinions in clients and occupational therapists on the process of client-centered practice in four facilities: long-term-care or rehabilitation, hospital outpatient, hospital inpatient, and nursing homes. RESULTS. The occupational therapists in this study indicated use of the principles of client-centered practice in their delivery of occupational therapy services. Their clients, however, displayed mixed perceptions about their role as active participants in client-centered practice and all responded in the negative when asked if they were aware of the approach. Perceptual differences existed between the occupational therapists and their clients in relation to the use of client-centered practice, because their responses to similar questions varied. Last, type of facility significantly influenced clients’ knowledge of certain aspects of their treatment processes in the following four areas: (a) treatment goal selection, (b) encouragement provided in setting clients’ goals, (c) clients’ perception of the importance in the goal-setting process, and (d) education of clients about their participatory role in the goal-setting process. CONCLUSION. Results suggest that a perceptual gap exists between occupational therapists and their clients in relation to their stated use of and participation in client-centered practice. In light of the results, development of a systematic strategy by occupational therapists to elicit the roles that their clients desire to play in the therapeutic process may be an effective intervention to ensure that occupational therapists and their clients are able to fulfill their roles in client-centered practice.

6 件のコメント:

  1. おつかれさまです.ウエズです.
    「CL中心実践プロセスに関するCLの認識が変化するのか」
    実感としては理解できるのですが,証明しようと思うと条件を明確化して統一するのが難しい気がしますね.この評価ツールがあれば必然的にCLとの協業が不可欠になると思われますので,実現可能かもしれませんね.楽しみです

    返信削除
  2. 条件の統一化 というのは母集団の統制ですかね?
    そうですね.同じ人で比べられればいいのですが,先にADOCをやると後のオープンの会話に,オープンの会話をすると後のADOCに影響がでてしまうので,まるっきり別の集団で,母集団を統制してデータを取るほうがいいのかなと思っています.これも母集団を統制するという点でバイアスが入るのですが,研究自体の実現可能性も考えて,そっちの方向で行こうかと思います.ただボスに相談ですが.

    返信削除
  3. It's a pity you don't have a donate button!

    I'd most certainly donate to this excellent blog! I suppose for now i'll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account.
    I look forward to new updates and will talk about this blog with my Facebook group.
    Talk soon!

    my page michael kors hamilton

    返信削除
  4. There may be noticeably a bundle to find out
    about this. I assume you made sure nice points in options also.


    Check out my page; nike shox nz

    返信削除
  5. I precisely wished to thank you so much again. I'm not certain the things I might have done in the absence of those opinions discussed by you over such a subject matter. It previously was a difficult circumstance for me personally, nevertheless observing the well-written style you managed it took me to weep with happiness. Now i am thankful for your help as well as pray you realize what a great job your are putting in instructing many others via your webpage. I am sure you've never encountered all of
    us.

    my web-site - rose gold michael kors watch

    返信削除
  6. F*ckin� awesome things here. I am very glad to see your article.
    Thanks a lot and i am looking forward to contact you.
    Will you please drop me a e-mail?

    Feel free to surf to my page: michael kors watch sale

    返信削除

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...